I was in the gifted program throughout my elementary and middle school years. During high school, there was no gifted program per se, but I was in the highest level math and science courses available for the grade in which I was in.
I was also bullied as a child. Heck, I've even been bullied as an adult. Bullies! Evil things they are!
It's a bit surprising to me that there is so little scientific research on the topic of bullies and giftedness. There is the
stereotypical view that all super smart kids are bullied. I think most of us realize that isn't true. At a school (now defunct) for gifted children that I once worked in, very few of the kids were bullied. However, I say this with a bit of reluctance. In some grades, none of the kids were bullied. In other grades, there were many kids that were bullied. It all just depended on what kind of kids were in the classes. If there were bullies in the class, then there were kids that got bullied. If there weren't bullies in the class, then the other kids in the class didn't get bullied.
One of the most noted and most recent
studies on bullying and the gifted comes from Jean Sunde Peterson and Karen E. Ray from Purdue University. A survey was given to 432 8th grade students identified as gifted. Contrary to my hypothesis that most gifted children are bullied, only 67% of these students indicated they were bullied sometime between Kindergarten and 8th grade. 54% of the males and 38% of females said they were bullied in 6th grade. Numbers declined slightly for males in 7th and 8th grade and held steady for females. 14% of the male students and 8% of the female students reported being repeatedly bullied in 6th grade. I would have been in this category from 6th grade through 10th grade, although I doubt I would have admitted it on a survey.
While 67% may seem high, another study conducted with students of all abilities, revealed that 75% of students had been bullied sometime during their school years (Hoover, Oliver, and Hazler, 1992). Yet another study among students with all abilities showed that 89% of elementary school children had been the target of at least one agressive attack (Orpinas, Home, and Staniszewski, 2003). While each of these studies are conducted a bit differently, the trend seems to be a higher percentage of the general population is bullied than the gifted community. This is opposite the stereotypical perception, and my original hypothesis.
I would like to see this study on bullying among the gifted replicated and enhanced. To enhance this study:
- Get more school districts involved in the study. 34 school districts were contacted, only 16 participated. Of those 16, the researchers already had connections with 12 of the districts. I'm going off on a tangent from the subject here, but I do think more schools have to start participating in studies on gifted children if we are to accurately educate them as well as support them socially and emotionally.
- Get more participants from each school. The study indicates that between 8% and 80% of eligible students at each district participated. 80% is pretty good, but 8%? That is not significant. Do some children choose not participate due to embarrassment of being bullied? Do some children choose not participate because they have never been bullied and thus feel they survey is lame? What are the reasons 20% to 92% of the students in each district did not participate?
- Get surveys from homeschooled gifted students. Through my experiences, I have met many homeschooled students that were pulled out of their schools, both public and private, due to bullying. None of these kids were able to participate in this study.
- Get surveys from as many gifted camps as possible. Gifted camps have students from a wide variety of backgrounds. 2% of the participants, or about 26 students, in this study were from camps.
- Provide a break down of students. What are the percentages from students in dedicated gifted programs? How about those that have no dedicated gifted program? What is the percentage of students bullied at private schools? Schools for the gifted? Homeschooled? What about those who are twice-exceptional, having ADHD, Asperger Syndrome, or any other outside-the-box thinking and behavior patterns?
Based on my on prejudicial experiences, I believe that gifted kids, in traditional schools, do often get bullied. At a boarding school I worked at, I saw most all of the gifted kids get bullied. Some weren't bullied only by students, but also by teachers and administrators. As one who supports the gifted kids, this drove me up the wall. The staff wouldn't bully them directly, but during staff meetings, they would often make condescending remarks. When the discussion of a kid getting bullied come up, the response would often be they deserved it. In one of these cases, one student was physically assaulted by another student. I was never made aware of any discipline provided to the person who assaulted the other student. From what I could tell, there was none. Now, I understand many parents don't want their children disciplined by the school, but I do believe we have to have some sort of order so that future attacks could be prevented.
At Golden Tree Academy, I hope to be able to provide an environment that is free from bullying. I want the students to feel safe, secure, and cared for. If a student does bully another student, I expect the administration, teachers, and parents to all work together to help the student and to prevent the student from bullying again in the future.
Til next time....
Bryan